The Bahamian blue exterior of Blackfly the Restaurant in St. Augustine.

Blackfly the Restaurant

High-class surf and turf dinner restaurant with creatively curated and locally sourced dishes.

Just over the Bridge of Lions on Anastasia Island.
108 Anastasia Blvd., St. Augustine, 32080
  • (904) 201-6300

Hours of Operation

Come In, We're Open!
Sun - Thu:
4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
Fri - Sat:
4:00 pm - 10:00 pm

  • Since 2012, Blackfly the Restaurant has prepared and presented fresh seafood dishes paired with local vegetables and fruits to create delicious dinners for their patrons.

    Blackfly Outfitters has long been known as a premier fly-fishing shop in Jacksonville and Blackfly Lodge and Cafe has delighted travelers in the Bahamas.  In 2012, Blackfly's owners, Vaughn and Jean Cochran, teamed up with Collage Restaurant owners, Mike Hyatt and Cindy Stangby and local friends Doug and Charlene Bunnell to bring this internationally known name to the nation's oldest city in the form of a seafood and steakhouse restaurant

    Diners at Blackfly the Restaurant will enjoy delicious entrees while seated in a bright dining room. The owners say the menu at Blackfly the Restaurant is "as varied as shells on the beach." Those who crave Bahamian conch, Maine lobster, or any type of seafood, are sure to enjoy how the chef at Blackfly the Restaurant prepares it. Those who prefer food from the land, from chicken to pork to steak, will not be disappointed. Blackfly is known as a "scratch kitchen," which means all of the ingredients used by the chefs are as fresh and local as they can be.

    Blackfly the Restaurant is located on Anastasia Island just over the Bridge of Lions from historic downtown St. Augustine. The Shores Bar in the back of the restaurant is available for private parties and special events.

  • Comments or Questions?

    My husband and I decided to try this last night for his birthday. What a delightful place. The decor was nice. Our only complaint was that is was a little loud last night but don't know if that is the norm. We had the specials which was a pan seared flounder which melted in my mouth. Everything was wonderful. Prices are fair for this kind of cuisine. I recommend to anyone visiting St Augustine.

    Beautiful nautical decor and artwork, and the best bar at the beach. Always outstanding food, great service, and a warm, friendly atmosphere. Now a first-rate restaurant at the beach.

    If you are looking for quality seafood that melts in your mouth, this IS the place to go. The food is phenomenal!!! The staff is friendly and attentive and the restaurant itself is beautiful!!!! I give this place a 10.. hands down the best place we have been to on our trip to St. Augustine.... This will definitely be on the top of our list of places to go when we visit!!!!

    Add new Comment

Things to Do Near Blackfly the Restaurant

Inside Anastasia Bizarre Bazaar in St. Augustine, FL.
Anastasia Bizarre Bazaar
0.1 miles away
Eclections, Inc. on Anastasia in St. Augustine.
0.2 miles away
Inside Ayla's Acres Thriftique in St. Augustine, FL
Ayla's Acres Thriftique
0.3 miles away
Ancient City Charters
0.3 miles away