Peace Pie

A Sweet Spin on Ice Cream Sandwiches

Located on historic Aviles Street, Peace Pie is home to the only patented ice cream sandwich made with shortbread cookies and house-made pie fillings. This locally loved dessert shop serves up a playful twist on a classic treat, with flavors that range from nostalgic to unexpected.

Peace Pie has become a favorite stop for visitors exploring the oldest street in the nation, offering a fun and flavorful way to cool off or cap off a night out in St. Augustine’s historic district.

What’s on the Menu

At Peace Pie, the star of the show is the ice cream sandwich, stacked with layers of creamy ice cream, house-made pie filling, and buttery shortbread cookies. The flavor list is both broad and creative, with options like:

• Banana Cream
• Blueberry Cobbler
• Caramel Coffee Toffee
• Chocolate Mint
• Cinnamon Bun
• Crème Brûlée
• Peanut Butter Blondie
• S’mores
• Strawberry Shortcake
• And seasonal creations like Pumpkin Latte and Double Pumpkin

Whether you’re in the mood for something fruity, chocolatey, or completely indulgent, there’s a Peace Pie with your name on it.

Catering & Delivery

Peace Pie offers catering and delivery, with a variety of themed packages available in quantities from six to 24. Collections include:

• Peace Pie Classics
• Chocolate Obsession
• Caramel Heaven
• For the Love of Peanut Butter & Chocolate
• Fresh as Fruit

Custom bundles are also available, making Peace Pie a fun and unique option for parties, events, or surprise gifts.

Know Before You Go

Peace Pie is located at 8 Aviles Street and is open daily from 10:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Seating is limited—the walk-up style makes it easy to grab a treat while exploring Historic Downtown.

The shop is family-friendly, and service animals are welcome. Flavors rotate regularly, so repeat visits are part of the fun.

Ice cream is a delicious way to beat the heat, but there's more than one way to cool down on a hot day. Check out Places to Swim in St. Augustine.