Italian

Get a taste of the old country at the many delicious and award-winning Italian restaurants in St. Augustine. Delicious pastas, pizzas, chicken dishes, and more await visitors at the local Italian restaurants in town. Enjoy fresh-made dishes prepared with local ingredients! There are great Italian eateries that offer quick bites as well as charming, sit-down restaurants serving up all the Italiano you could want.

180 Vilano Grill and Pizza

(904) 827-1009
180 Vilano Rd.
180 Vilano is located in charming Vilano Beach, just a short walk from the Vilano Bier.

Dine inside or on the patio just a block from Vilano Beach and enjoy pizza, seafood, sandwiches, and Italian specialities.

Al's Pizza

(904) 824-4383
1 St. George Street

Located just across from St. Augustine's Castille de San Marcos, Al's Pizza offers hand-made pizza and a variety of other Italian specialties.

Amici Italian Restaurant

(904) 461-0102
1915 A1A South

Diners will enjoy authentic and delicious Italian food made from scratch, as well as a cozy dining atmosphere, at Amici's Restaurant in St. Augustine.

Antonio's Pizza - A1A Beach Blvd.

(904) 471-5200
378 A1A Beach Blvd.

Try authentic and fresh Italian food at this New York style pizzeria.

Antonio's Pizza - South

(904) 794-0117
934 Santa Maria Blvd

Enjoy fresh and delicious thin-crust pizza everyday from this local pizzeria.

Bistro 206

(904) 342-2171
811 FL 206
Bistro 206 in St. Augustine.

Bistro 206 is a comfortably elegant restaurant, serving dishes from a select menu.

Borrillo's Pizzeria & Beer Garden

(904) 829-1133
88 San Marco Ave.

The chef is from Brooklyn, so the pizza is true New York Style Pizza, and the beer garden is a great place to gather.

Cafe del Hidalgo

(904) 823-1196
35 Hypolita St

A variety of lunch and dinner items — as well as beer, wine, bellinis, and homemade Italian Ice Cream — are available at this downtown café.

Carmelo's Pizzeria

(904) 494-6658
146 King Street
Carmelo's Pizzeria offers New-York-style pizza made from scratch in St. Augustine, FL.

Carmelo's Marketplace delivers old-world quality — deliciously.

Carrabba's Italian Grill

(904) 819-9093
155 SR 312 West

Carrabba's Italian Grill in St. Augustine, Florida is a casual dining restaurant that serves flavorful Italian dishes prepared from fresh ingredients.

Casa Benedetto's

(904) 471-5999
197F Blackford Way
The entrace for the new Casa Benedetto's in St. Augustine.

Formerly in Vilano, this family-run Italian restaurant has moved to a new location off Dixie highway south of St. Augustine.

Chianti Room

(904) 825-4100
60 Charlotte Street

The Chianti Room offers great pizza to eat in or to go, as well a full Italian dinner menu from calamari to cannoli.

Cino's Pizza

(904) 940-4445
425 West Town Place #114

Cino's Pizza, where everyone is family, serves pizza, pasta, stromboli, and more.

Cucina Giovanni

(904) 823-8999
2730 State Road 16
Cucini Giovanni at Route 16 in St. Augustine.

Cucini Giovanni presents Italian meals, appetizers, pizzas, and subs.

De Leon Pizza

(904) 794-1917
84 Theatre Drive

This local pizza shop is right next to Epic Theatre in St. Augustine

Gelato Time

(904) 819-0133
122 St. George Street

Visitors and locals can dine on authentic Italian gelato at this eatery next-door to Pizza Time.

Joni's Pizza

(904) 810-0702
145 Hilden Road, Suite 118

Joni's Pizza creats fresh pizza and Italian specialties in St. Augustine.

Napoli's Pastaria

(904) 273-0006
3787 Palm Valley Rd
Outside of Napoli's Pastaria in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fl

Napoli's Pastaria in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida provides Italian dishes in a family atmosphere. They offer lunch, dinner, and catering. Some of their popular dishes include Penne Alla Vodka, Veal Parmigiana, and Chicken Piccata. 

Ned's Southside Kitchen

(904) 794-2088
2450 US Highway 1 S

This friendly local restaurant serves a surprisingly varied menu.

New York Pizza Co.

(904) 825-4545
163 Palencia Village Drive #101

The New York Pizza Company makes pizza, pastas, and appetizers to eat in or to take out.