Italian

Get a taste of the old country at the many delicious and award-winning Italian restaurants in St. Augustine. Delicious pastas, pizzas, chicken dishes, and more await visitors at the local Italian restaurants in town. Enjoy fresh-made dishes prepared with local ingredients! There are great Italian eateries that offer quick bites as well as charming, sit-down restaurants serving up all the Italiano you could want.

Al's Pizza

(904) 824-4383
1 St. George Street

Al's Pizza offers pizzas made from scratch and a varied menu of Italian cuisine in the heart of downtown St. Augustine.

Amici Italian Restaurant

(904) 461-0102
1915 A1A South

For authentic and delicious Italian food made from scratch come by Amici's Restaurant and enjoy a cozy dining atmosphere as well.

Antonio's Pizza - A1A Beach Blvd.

(904) 471-5200
378 A1A Beach Blvd.

Try authentic and fresh Italian food at this New York style pizzeria. Always offering hot, fresh pizza made with fresh ingredients.

Antonio's Pizza - South

(904) 794-0117
934 Santa Maria Blvd

Enjoy fresh and delicious pizza everyday from this local pizzeria.

Borrillo's Pizza & Subs

(904) 829-1133
88 San Marco Ave.

Borrillo's Pizza and Subs serves New York style pizza and more in a convenient location directly across the street from the Mission Nombre de Dios, just north of St. Augustine's historic district.

Carmelo's Marketplace

(904) 429-0046
146 King Street

Carmelo's Marketplace offers fresh Italian food made from scratch on site, with daily specials such as pizza by the slice, grilled ciabatta panini, fresh salads, calzones, meatball subs and more!

Carrabba's Italian Grill

(904) 819-9093
155 SR 312 West

Carrabba's Italian Grill in St. Augustine, Florida is a casual dining restaurant that serves flavorful Italian dishes prepared from fresh ingredients.

Casa Benedetto's

(904) 471-5999
165 Vilano Road
Casa Benedetto's Restaurant on Vilano Beach is a hidden gem in St. Augustine.

This family-run Italian restaurant in Vilano Beach is one of St. Augustine's hidden gems.

Chianti Room

(904) 825-4100
60 Charlotte Street

Order Italian plates, appetizers, drinks, and more at this dining spot just off St. George Street.

Cino's Pizza

(904) 940-4445
425 West Town Place #114

Cino's Pizza is an Italian restaurant in St. Augustine, located at the World Golf Village. Here customers will find a variety of oven baked pizzas. Both New York Style and Sicilian style pizza is served at this restaurant.

Cucina Giovanni

(904) 823-8999
2730 State Road 16

Cucina Giovanni Italian Restaurant offers classic Italian food at affordable prices. This St. Augustine restaurant is conveniently located next to the Saint Augustine Outlet Malls and I-95.

De Leon Pizza

(904) 794-1917
84 Theatre Drive

De Leon Pizza is a located next to the Epic Theatre complex in St. Augustine. The restaurant offers slices and whole pizzas, as well as calzones, sub sandwiches, chicken wings and more.

Gelato Time

(904) 819-0133
122 St. George Street

Visitors and locals can dine on authentic Italian gelato at this eatery next-door to Pizza Time.

Joni's Pizza

(904) 810-0702
145 Hilden Road, Suite 118

Joni's Pizza and Italian Restaurant offers fresh homemade Italian and an enjoyable atmosphere to dine in! Located off Hilden Rd. in Ponte Vedra, Florida this restaurant specializes in real Italian food.

La Pentola Restaurant

(904) 824-3282
58 Charlotte St
Enjoy the fine dining experience offered at La Pentola in St. Augustine.

For a refined atmosphere, exquisite dining, and authentic Italian and Mediterranean food come to La Pentola in downtown St. Augustine.

New York Pizza Co.

(904) 825-4545
163 Palencia Village Drive #101

New York Pizza Company located at Palencia Village in historic Saint Augustine is serving up a slice of New York style! Come by for a delicious slice of pizza any day of the week.

Nonna's Trattoria

(904) 891-0318
2 Aviles Street
The sidewalk cafe at Nonna's Trattoria on Aviles Street in St. Augustine, Florida.

Nonna's Trattoria offers the traditional Italian experience with delicious food, a lively atmosphere and a beautiful location on historic Aviles Street.

PIZZA DINA

(904) 826-3535
100 St. George Street

This Italian restaurant serves fresh and authentic cuisine on St. George Street.

Pizza Time

(904) 819-0133
124 St. George St.

A little slice of New York has arrived and the friendly staff at Pizza Time is happy to serve visitors and locals in St. Augustine.

Pizzalley's

(904) 825-2627
117 St. George Street
Pizzalley's is located in the heart of historic St. Augustine, Florida.

Order quick-service pizza at the counter, or sit down for a full dining experience at the Chianti Room.