Antonio's Pizza - South
Antonio's New York Style Pizza serves authentic New York style pizza with a great crust and delicious homemade sauce. There are two locations in St. Augustine -- this one in the St. Augustine Shores area (at 934 Santa Maria Blvd.) and one on Anastasia Island (378 A1A Beach Blvd.)
The restaurant's laid-back atmosphere makes it a an ideal spot to enjoy some of the finest pizza in the area. Antonio's serves pizza by the pie or by the slice, and includes sandwiches, salads, and pasta on their menu, all at reasonable prices. They offer dine-in, take-out, and delivery.