3 Blind Dates trio

Under the Mistletoe with 3 Blind Dates - an Unscripted Romantic Comedy

The audience's holiday love stories inspire this improvised rom com.

Saturday, Dec. 5, 2026 | 8:00 p.m. - 9:30 p.m.

Under the Mistletoe with 3 Blind Dates - an Unscripted Romantic Comedy

(904) 342-7299

2 blocks behind Carmelo's Pizza
200 Malaga Street
St Augustine, FL 32084

Share This

Third Space Improv presents Under the Mistletoe with 3 Blind Dates—an unscripted romantic comedy—on Saturday, December 5, 2026 at 8:00 p.m.

An unscripted romantic comedy, inspired by the audience's summer love stories, 3 Blind Dates follows three single ladies through a round of speed dating. The audience then selects a gentleman for each of the ladies and the dates unfold in real time on stage. The material for each date is mined from the audience's holiday love stories that are shared with cast members in the studio before the show.

3 Blind Dates has appeared in the 2015 Colorado Improv Festival and the 2015 Boulder International Fringe Festival. The show won “Best Improv Form” in the 2015 Colorado Improv Awards. Its Florida debut was on Valentine’s Day 2016 to a standing room only audience in Jacksonville. Since then it has appeared to full houses in St. Augustine and Jacksonville.

Third Space Improv offers wine, beer, soft drinks, fresh popcorn and other snacks in the Laughter Lounge 30 minutes before the show starts.

Admission: Tickets are $20.00 online in advance and $25.00 at the box office the evening of the performance. To purchase tickets online in advance, go here.

When: Saturday, December 5, 2026 at 8:00 p.m.

Where: Third Space Improv, 200 Malaga Street, St. Augustine, Florida 32084

There is free parking in the lot at Third Space Improv, so you can park, and enjoy the Nights of Lights on foot before or after the show, or, you can use the city's free shuttle service.

Parking and Shuttles During Nights of Lights

Nights of Lights is a event best enjoyed by walking or by taking a walking, riding, or boat tour.

There are two types of bus routes:

  1. Free Park and Ride Shuttles on select days. (See Below)
  2. Free STAR Circulator Bus on a loop between the Visitor Information Center and St. Augustine Beach.

Free Park and Ride Shuttles

  • Park for free in one of the lots outside of town.
  • Take a free shuttle bus to the Visitor Information Center, and enjoy Nights of Lights.
  • Then, meet the free shuttle bus at the Visitor Center and ride back to your car. 

When Do the Free Shuttles Operate in 2026/27?

  • 4:00 to 11:00 pm. on Light-Up! Night, November 21.
  • 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. on December 5 (the day of the Christmas Parade).
  • 1:00 to 11:00 p.m. on the remaining 21 high-attendance days during Nights of Lights.
    • November: 27 and 28
    • December: 4, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, and 31
    • January: 1 and 2

Where Will You Park? 

Three lots will be open on the days the shuttles operate:

Special Light-Up! Night Shuttle on Anastasia Island

On Saturday, November 21, 2026, from 4:00 to 11:00 p.m., park for free in one of two lots on Anastasia Island and use the Free Park-and-Ride Shuttle, provided by Historic Tours of America. 

  • Anastasia Baptist Church, 1650 A1A South
  • R.B. Hunt Elementary School, 125 Magnolia Drive (off A1A South)
  • You will have to walk across the Bridge of Lions to get to town and walk back across the bridge to take the shuttle.

Why Use the Lots and Shuttle Service?

  • It's free.
  • You avoid driving around (and around) the city looking for a parking spot.
  • When the shuttles are operating, the parking garage charges $40.00 after 1:00 p.m.
    • If you arrive before 1:00 p.m or on any day the shuttles don't operate the garage charges $20.00 for the day. 
    • St Johns County residents with ParkStAug pay normal resident price.
  • Neighborhoods bordering downtown enact Resident Only Parking on the streets during Nights of Lights. There will be private paid lots in the area, but no on-street parking.

Busiest Days with Heavy Traffic

You can absolutely enjoy these days. Just plan to arrive early.

Here are the special events that will impact the traffic and the shuttles:

  • Light-UP! Night, Saturday, November 21—Added shuttles from Anastasia start at 4:00 p.m.
  • Christmas Parade, Saturday, December 5—The shuttles start operating at 8:00 a.m.
  • Regatta of Lights, Saturday, December 12, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. Coming from Ponte Vedra? View the boats from the Vilano Fishing Pier. Coming from Anastasia? View the boats from the bridge. The viewing space on the bayfront is limited due to construction.

Under the Mistletoe with 3 Blind Dates - an Unscripted Romantic Comedy

(904) 342-7299

2 blocks behind Carmelo's Pizza
200 Malaga Street
St Augustine, FL 32084

Share This

Admission | Ticket Prices

$20.00 online, $25.00 at the door

Have a Question?

Related categories

Cannon Firing at the Castillo de San Marcos

Featured Events

Musicians playing at the St. Augustine Celtic Festival

Festivals

A magician lights a straw man that is standing in his left palm

Live Entertainment

The composer faces the St. Augustine Community Chorus as they perform in the Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine

Arts & Culture

People paddling kayaks toward the sunset in Guana

Sports & Outdoors

For Kids

Historical

Snowman of lights in the Plaza for Nights of Lights

Seasonal

Food

Local Things to Do

Fundraisers

Editor's Note: We encourage you to verify event times and details with the organizers, as they may change.