The Black Molly Grill in St. Augustine, FL

Black Molly Grill

Locally owned and operated, this casual joint offers a diverse menu in a family-style setting.

In the Cobblestone Plaza
504 W Geoffrey Street, St. Augustine, 32086
  • (904) 547-2723

Hours of Operation

Come In, We're Open!
Sun - Thu:
11:00 am - 9:00 pm
Fri - Sat:
11:00 am - 10:00 pm

  • This casual dining restaurant, specializing in great seafood, juicy steaks, and chicken, is great for a family night out or to share a leisurely meal for two.

    Choices abound at Black Molly Grill, where owners (and St. Augustine locals) Jason Hamilton and Ryan Torboli are delighted to work together to a create an outstanding local restaurant. Their menu includes Shrimp Po Boy or Homemade Burger for lunch and Mediterranean Salad, Hand Cut Filet, or any of their seafood specialties for dinner.

    They offer lunch, dinner, beer wine, and special cocktails and are open until ten on weekends.

  • Comments or Questions?

    paula sharp on April 14, 2018 - 7:46pm

    We had the stuffed mushrooms. Pretty good. I had the scallops/shrimp with this sauce I have never tasted and it was the best shrimp/scallops I have ever eaten. The sauce made it over the top. They were cooked just right. The rolls were just ok but the butter made them better. I wish wasn't leaving so early tomorrow because I would love to go back for more!! The restaurant was very clean and all of the staff were really nice.

    Steve Parsons on August 18, 2012 - 6:28pm

    This review was childish....read all reviews...read his poor punctuation...I had same spinach and was amazed by the delicate way it was prepared...It was perfect...guy must hate pepper...I've lived in St Augustine for 32 years and know what locals love to eat....this place is great with very good prices for what you get. St. Augustine has no steakhouse but consider this place...best filet in town!! Combine that with local fresh fish and creative home made sauces and dressings and you'll be hooked. Service was beyond wonderful....they 'GET IT' !

    Anonymous on August 9, 2012 - 9:48pm

    Good experience. Will probably go back.

    Janice Bashaw on July 21, 2012 - 7:37pm

    Just moved to Saint Augustine and had been looking for a good restaurant. Tried Black Molly Grill and instantly became my favorite place to eat. The food is beyond excellent and the service is next to none. A great dining experience from start to finish!!

    Anonymous on June 12, 2012 - 4:47pm

    We are making this a weekly dining destination. Everything we have tried has been delicious. Love their sauces! Local owners - using local products! Obviously take pride in what they serve. Can't say enough about the friendly wait staff!

    Betsy on March 22, 2012 - 8:45pm

    We have visited Black Molly two times, and both meals were FAB!!! Really nice salad, fish - PERFECT and great sides- how about fresh asparagus with grated cheese, grits and goat cheese cakes with a lovely light tomato coulis, welI could go on , but if you want a quaiity meal, get yourselves over to Black Molly. Service is great, and happy hour gives half price house wines and draft beer. ENJOY!!! We will be back SOON!!!

    Gina on February 7, 2012 - 4:28pm

    We went with a party of 4 on a Friday night and they looked slammed. We were concerned about quality of food and service, but to our surprise the food came out in a timely manner and everything tasted delicous! We loved the 5 options of fresh local caught fish and the other different ways you could have them prepared. Our server, who was obviously busy kept her cool and was very pleasant. We will definetly be back!

    Don on January 10, 2012 - 10:34pm

    Worst meal I have ever overpaid for. Everything had so much. Pepper that it was impossible to eat. Spinach was drowning in oil. Will never eat there again!

    Doris McCabe on September 8, 2011 - 7:17pm

    John Collins kept the pace of the meal just right. Not hurried but every need anticipated. The meals were great - not just the seafood but the chicken, too. Can't beat the value - 2 for 1 house drinks and all entrees under $20. Owner Ryan is to be congratulated! It's a nice place to spend an evening.

    Valarie Dennard on September 5, 2011 - 8:03am

    Last night was my first experience at the Black Molly Grill, but it will definitely not be my last. The staff were friendly and engaging which only served to make my experience that more enjoyable. The food? My entree choice, Hypolita Chicken, was absolutely delicious and a must-try dish when you dine here. Splurge on dessert and have the Gorilla Vanilla Cheesecake - outstanding! Thank you, Black Molly Grill for a wonderful dining experience last night. See you soon!

    Xemplifly on August 31, 2011 - 2:37pm

    My wife and I ate here last night. I had the encrusted salmon with sweet potato. My wife had the San Marcos Chicken with vegetable medley and smashed potatoes. Our entrees were delivered hot and smelled fantastic. The salmon and chicken were both exceptional. Well prepared and flavorful. Pros: Good Food and Service. Cons: Unwelcoming Exterior. Interior lacks personality. Price seems high for the atmosphere; be prepared to drop half a Benjamin on two - without drinks. Just a side note: If you have the spinach and artichoke dip, be sure to knock the excess salt off the blue chips first... Wow, they like 'em salty.

    Linda on August 16, 2011 - 3:27pm

    Wow! We tried this place today after shopping and were absolutely amazed. It's outstanding - very very good, finally a place to have lunch in St. Augustine!! Way to go!

    Kari on August 15, 2011 - 5:53pm

    Fresh food, not-all-fried, and a great, laid-back atmosphere.

    Linda on August 1, 2011 - 10:40am

    Great host! A young man that clearly knew what he was doing. Great waitress, Rebecca, really friendly and helpful. Great food, ill be coming back!

    Denis Patrick on July 20, 2011 - 8:27pm

    I have been in St. Augustine for five years and have never found a place that has it all under one roof. I'm from New york City and in the restaurant bizz for 39 years they really impressed me from the front door. The partners know what to do , and it shows. I've gone twice in two weeks and plan on returning this week. Keep it going guys, the food really is perfect ; real crab cakes, salads ,fish and pasta's Go if your near St.Augustine

    Add new Comment

Things to Do Near Black Molly Grill

Inside Second Time Around thrift store in St. Augustine, FL.
Second Time Around
0.5 miles away
Epic Movie Theatre
0.7 miles away
Father and son fishing trip
High Tailin' Fishing Charters
0.8 miles away
Raging Water Sports
0.8 miles away

Profile Keywords

Seafood Steaks