Borrillo's Pizzeria and Beer Garden serves New York-style pizza across the street from the Mission Nombre de Dios, just north of the Historic District. The chef is from Brooklyn, so the pizza is authentic New York-style. The beer garden has a relaxed vibe and is a popular gathering spot for locals.
Borrillo's restaurant has a small dining area with booths for guests to dine in and outside seating at the beer garden. They also offer an extensive carry-out menu and free delivery to most of St. Augustine.
Borrillo's menu includes fresh salads, specialty pizza, calzones, subs, stromboli, sausage rolls, pizza by the slice, Philly cheesesteaks, and pasta.