Carmelo's Pizzeria

Carmelo's Pizzeria offers New York Style pizza made from scratch — from tossing the fresh-made pizza dough, to making the sauce and preparing the toppings, to baking in a brick oven set to 500 degrees. The full menu includes pizzas, hot or cold subs, calzones, Stromboli, various pasta dishes, and appetizers. They also offer a gluten-free, 10-inch pizza.

Named for family patriarch Carmelo Tringali who emigrated from Sicily to work in St. Augustine as a shrimper, Carmelo's Pizzeria is located at 146 King Street, where it is attached to the convenience store and gas station, Carmelo's Marketplace.