New York Pizza Co.

The New York Pizza Company makes pizza, pastas, and appetizers to eat in or to take out.

East of Dixie Highway, Route 1 near International Golf Parkway.
163 Palencia Village Drive #101, St. Augustine, 32095
  • (904) 825-4545

Hours of Operation

Come In, We're Open!
12:00 pm - 8:00 pm
11:00 am - 8:00 pm
Tue - Thu:
11:00 am - 9:00 pm
Fri - Sat:
11:00 am - 10:00 pm

  • New York Pizza Company, located at Palencia Village in historic Saint Augustine, serves New York-style pizza seven days a week. This Italian restaurant also offers appetizers, sandwiches, pastas, calzones, and more.

    At New York Pizza Company, guests can order from a long list of toppings and options, so their pizza or pasta dish is exactly as they prefer. Those with a sensitivity to gluten may order a gluten-free pizza for one, and there are plenty of choices for both vegetarians and those who want a pizza or pasta dish loaded with meat. New York Pizza Company offers wine, beer, and soft drinks; soups and salads; and New York Specialty Heroes.

    Guests may dine in, get their meal to go, order in advance for a quick pick-up, or have their meal delivered.

  • Comments or Questions?

    We came to try and were won over with the wonderful pizza. Great thin NY crust and fillings were great......

    Was this Review Helpful?

    I loved the pizza. Delicious wings too. This place has the best pizza in St. Augustine and the restaurant is totally family friendly.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Add new Comment

Things to Do Near New York Pizza Co.

the palencia club pond view
The Palencia Club
1.0 miles away
Tolomato River Boardwalk located in Palencia
Tolomato Boardwalk
1.4 miles away
The front entrance to Out There Antiques in St. Johns Country.
Out There Antiques
2.1 miles away