The entrace for the new Casa Benedetto's in St. Augustine.

Casa Benedetto's

Formerly in Vilano Beach, this family-run Italian restaurant is now located off Dixie Highway in South St. Augustine.

Located in the Plaza behind Walmart's south of St. Augustine.
197F Blackford Way, St. Augustine, 32086
  • (904) 471-5999

Hours of Operation

Come In, We're Open!
Sun:
Closed
Mon - Thu:
12:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Fri - Sat:
12:00 pm - 9:00 pm

  • Casa Benedetto's Ristorante has opened at their new location, 197 Blackford Way, Unit F, St. Augustine.

    Casa Benedetto's Ristorante offers traditional authentic homemade Italian cuisine carefully prepared from old family recipes. Popular specialties include brasiole, chicken cacciatore, rice balls, homemade manicotti, zuppa de peche, scungilli salad, veal sorrentino, chicken marsala, fettucini alfredo, and penne a la vodka.

    Casa Benedetto's offer a wide variety of homemade desserts, including tiramisu, cheesecake, Italian cookies, chocolate mocha cake, cassata parfait and cannoli. Casa Benedetto's also offers gelato and sorbet. Espresso and cappuccino are available as well.

  • Comments or Questions?

    Joan Donato on December 19, 2019 - 12:47am

    5
    A genuine home-cooked meal that is a piece of New York at its best. I've been a loyal fan since they were newly-opened in Crescent Beach (before Vilano) and they have never disappointed me. Jay and Robyn are wonderful proprietors and make sure their customers are happy and well-fed. They are also very accommodating if able to do so. I've considered them friends for a long time and believe they are a wonderful contribution to the community.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Regina on October 9, 2017 - 12:02pm

    5
    Everything about this restaurant is wonderful - the food, the owners and staff, the atmosphere, the food!! We've been here several times and always have the same great experience. Our last visit was days after Hurricane Irma and they had only just reopened, yet everyone was friendly and the food was delicious. Their tiramisu is amazing!

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Susan on August 17, 2015 - 11:37pm

    5
    My husband and I lucked up on this wonderful restaurant last year. Ate here 3 times during a 4 day visit. We are planning another trip to St. Augustine in Sept. and look forward to dining at Casa Benedetto's again. The ingredients are fresh and prepared Sicilian style. The tiramisu is on another scale than any other I have tried. Also enjoyed conversations with management and staff.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Morgan on February 17, 2015 - 1:44pm

    5
    Ate lunch today- 1st visit. Food was delicious. Great wait staff. Nice atmosphere. Can't wait to go back for dinner!!

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Anonymous on March 16, 2012 - 8:39am

    3
    Food was okay - but not great

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Sarah Morris on November 7, 2011 - 9:46am

    5
    This is the best Italian I've had since New York. Just like Mom use to make.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Linda on October 18, 2011 - 7:46am

    5
    Salad was fresh and crisp. Pasta cooked perfect. Heard the chicken being pounded in the kitchen. Carnolli's were great. Will be back next month to try something different.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    You voted 'No'.

    Gina on June 17, 2011 - 7:09pm

    5
    My husband

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Sonja on March 18, 2011 - 2:25pm

    5
    We have eaten here several times and it has been fantastic every time! Great home cooked Italian specialties. Friendly owners and waitresses.

    Was this Review Helpful?

    Add new Comment

Things to Do Near Casa Benedetto's

Xscape Our Rooms
within 1 block
St. Augustine Shores Golf Club in St. Augustine, FL.
St. Augustine Shores Golf Club
0.7 miles away
The exterior of Classic Car Museum of St. Augustine is reminiscent of a filling station from the last century.
Classic Car Museum of St. Augustine
0.8 miles away
The playground at Canopy Shores
Canopy Shores Park
2.0 miles away