Pizza Time

Brooklyn-Style Pizza

Located on St. George Street in Historic Downtown, Pizza Time offers a taste of Brooklyn in the Oldest City. Known for its crisp, foldable slices and true New York-style crust, this popular no-frills pizzeria serves up fresh, made-to-order pies alongside classic Italian favorites.

Pizza by the Slice or the Whole Pie

Pizza Time offers a rotating selection of ready-made pizzas by the slice, which makes it easy for guests to grab a quick bite while walking around town. Whole pies are also available and can be customized with the toppings of your choice. All pizzas are made with house sauce, fresh ingredients, and a traditional Brooklyn-style crust.

More Than Just Pizza

The menu at Pizza Time keeps things classic. In addition to its pizza offerings, Pizza Time serves up calzones, olive salad, and sweet Italian cannolis. After your meal, walk next door to Gelato Time, its sister shop, for a refreshing dessert to help beat the heat.

Local Favorites

Popular slices include pepperoni, white pizza with ricotta and spinach, sausage and peppers, and classic cheese. Many locals prefer the margherita with fresh tomato and basil or the buffalo chicken for something with a kick. The meat lover’s and vegetarian combo slices also make regular appearances on the menu and are a crowd favorite.

Pizza Time’s calzones, stuffed with mozzarella, ricotta, and your choice of meat or vegetables, are another popular choice. The olive salad is served cold and packed with green and black olives, peppers, and Italian seasoning. It's is a regular side for returning customers. For dessert, the cannoli is a simple but satisfyingly classic finish, filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips.

You’ll often see people walking out with a slice in hand and heading next door to Gelato Time, where popular flavors include pistachio, stracciatella, and lemon.

Indoor Seating and Free Parking

Pizza Time has indoor seating and a second entrance on Spanish Street, where guests can find metered parking. The Spanish Street entrance makes it easier to access the restaurant without walking through pedestrian-only areas.

Cash Only – Plan Ahead

Pizza Time does not take credit or debit cards. Guests should bring cash, though there is an ATM located on site should you forget.

Catering

Pizza Time offers catering for private events and gatherings. Just call (904) 819-0133 for details.