Spooky Sips in the Oldest City
Where to find Halloween cocktails in St. Augustine.
Haunted Happy Hours & Pop-Up Experiences
As the golden glow of fall settles on St. Augustine, and the nights become just a little extra spooky, the city's bar scene transforms with it. Here, you'll find no shortage of warming spices, creative cocktails, and seasonal shots. Mixologists across the city are putting their own spin on autumn’s favorite flavors. Whether you’re craving a “witch’s brew” before a ghost tour or a pumpkin-spiced pick-me-up between historic sites, these seasonal drinks are the tastiest way to savor October in St. Augustine. The city’s bartenders take Halloween as seriously as they take crafting cocktails. Many of St. Augustine’s best-loved watering holes use the season as a chance to experiment with new and familiar flavors. Here's a few places to find spooky cocktails, good times, and room to let loose (or even get a little groovy).
The Ice Plant
The Ice Plant, a Prohibition-era bar in a restored 1920s ice factory, is known for its farm-to-glass cocktails all year, and autumn brings a few extra surprises. Look for creations featuring cinnamon-infused bourbon, pumpkin purée, or smoked maple syrup—drinks designed to complement evening chills and ghostly walks through Historic Downtown.
Odd Birds Bar
Just down the road, Odd Birds Bar and speakeasy leans into Halloween with themed menus and dramatic presentations. Last year’s highlights included a jet-black mezcal concoction with activated charcoal and a candy corn-inspired old fashioned—and their bartenders promise even bolder seasonal experiments this fall.
Forgotten Tonic
For one night only, Aviles Street gets a spirited makeover as Forgotten Tonic hosts its annual Halloween Black Lagoon celebration on Friday, October 31, from 11:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m. This intimate craft cocktail lounge—known for its moody lighting, inventive drinks, and artful presentations—pulls out all the stops for the holiday. Expect eerie décor, flickering candlelight, and a menu of inventive drinks with names like Hex Appeal, Memento Mori, and Nosferatu’s Rise.
The Chatsworth
The seasonal cocktail menu at The Chatsworth has something for every palate, from bold and spicy to rich and cozy. Highlights include the Spicy Midnight Margarita, the refreshing Black Widow (a blueberry lemonade twist), the creamy Pumpkin RumChata Martini, the indulgent Pumpkin Espresso Martini, and the bright, nonalcoholic Bewitched Spritz.
Boat Drinks
Over in Uptown, Boat Drinks’ Haunted Hideaway offers a more playful twist on spooky season. Their themed cocktail menu pairs perfectly with classic horror films shown throughout October—from Ghostbusters to Beetlejuice. With a laid-back coastal vibe, clever seasonal drinks, and nostalgic movie nights, this event is a must-visit for anyone who likes their Halloween with a side of cinematic charm.
Prohibition Kitchen
And for those looking to dance the night away, Prohibition Kitchen brings a theatrical flair to the holiday with its annual Halloween bash. This year’s theme—Ride the Soul Train to Disco Inferno—turns the lively gastropub into a 70's retro dance party complete with groovy beats, dazzling costumes, and far-out cocktails.
Enjoy Your Halloween Libations
From eerie pop-ups and inventive themed menus to retro dance parties and cocktail-fueled movie nights, St. Augustine’s nightlife comes alive in unforgettable ways each October. Whether you’re chasing down the city’s spookiest sips or dressing up for a night of disco, there’s no shortage of ways to toast the city's spirits. Drink responsibly and enjoy your time in the Oldest City.
