Mouth-watering Italian dishes can be found at these restaurants in St. Augustine.

Italian

Get a taste of the old country at one of the many award-winning Italian restaurants in St. Augustine. Enjoy pastas, pizzas, chicken dishes, and more at these local Italian eateries, offering quick bites as well as romantic, sit-down meals.

Sponsored Partners

Ocean Sands Beach Boutique Inn
La Fiesta - Ocean Inn & Suites
La Fiesta - Ocean Inn & Suites
Beacher's Lodge - Oceanfront Suites
Beacher's Lodge - Oceanfront Suites

Italian

Delicious Italian entrees like chicken parmigiana, margherita pizza and more are made fresh daily at local St. Augustine Italian restaurants.
Pizza at Brucci's Pizza in Fruit Cove, Florida

Brucci's Pizza

(904) 287-8317

540 FL-13 #10

A fast-casual pizzeria serving an array of Italian-inspired dishes.

The wide selection of gelato flavors on display

Café del Hidalgo

(904) 823-1196

35 Hypolita St.

A quaint Italian restaurant serving lunch and dinner items.

Outside seating at Caffe Andiamo in Sawgrass Village

Caffe Andiamo

(904) 280-2299

500 Sawgrass Village Drive

An authentic Italian experience awaits at Sawgrass Village.

Carmelo's Pizzeria offers New-York-style pizza made from scratch in St. Augustine, FL.

Carmelo's Pizzeria

(904) 494-6658

146 King Street

Carmelo's Marketplace delivers old-world quality — deliciously.

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Carrabba's Italian Grill

(904) 819-9093

155 SR 312 West

A casual dining restaurant that serves flavorful Italian dishes prepared from fresh ingredients daily.

The entrace for the new Casa Benedetto's in St. Augustine.

Casa Benedetto's

(904) 471-5999

197F Blackford Way

Formerly in Vilano Beach, this family-run Italian restaurant is now located off Dixie Highway in South St. Augustine.

The porcini mushroom tortelloni presentation

Catullo's Italian

(904) 373-0504

100 Marketside Ave.

Homemade Italian food with a twist of fine dining.

Cortesse's pation in St. Augustine's Uptown neighborhood.

Cortesse's Bistro

(904) 217-0705

172 San Marco Ave.

Fine Mediterranean recipes and cooking made with fresh, local ingredients every day.

The exterior of the Cucina Giovanni building

Cucina Giovanni

(904) 823-8999

2730 S.R. 16

Enjoy an Italian meal at a place where everyone is treated like family.

The exterior of D'Aleo Italian Deli

D'Aleo Italian Deli

(904) 794-7672

2445 U.S. Highway 1 S

An Italian grocery and deli pays homage to its New York roots.

The exterior of the Galleno's Pizzeria food truck

Galleno's Pizzeria

(904) 728-1570

509 S Ponce de Leon Blvd.

Get a taste of Italy from this truck's signature Neapolitan pizza.

Related categories

Catch 27's take on Shrimp and Grits

Seafood

Family dining at O.C. White's seafood restaurant

Family Fare

The vintage-inspired bar at the Ice Plant restaurant in St. Augustine, FL

Bar / Lounge / Pub

Breakfast

St. Augustine boasts a number of fine dining establishments with menus to please the most discriminating palate.

Fine Dining

Enjoy as taste of old St. Augustine at one of these restaurants offering authentic tapas, paella, gazpacho soup, and much more.

Spanish

Hear live music from local, regional, and national musicians in St. Augustine's restaurants, bars, pubs, and lounges.

Live Entertainment

Mouth-watering Italian dishes can be found at these restaurants in St. Augustine.

Italian

St. Augustine offers locally owned steakhouses as well as several chain restaurants specializing in steaks.

Steaks

Local Chinese restaurants in St. Augustine offer all the favorites and some new flavors unique to the nation’s oldest city.

Chinese

C

Catering

Funkadelic Food Truck, now located at Dog Rose Brew Pub in St. Augustine.

Food Trucks

Asian Fusion restaurants mix Chinese, Thai, Japanese, and other cuisines from Asia.

Asian Fusion

Bagels

Bakery

St. Augustine's restaurants include a host of barbecue options to please every palate.

Barbeque

Several restaurants in St. Augustine offer delicious British food and pub meals.

British

Enjoy a mouth-watering brunch at one of these St. Augustine restaurants.

Brunch

St. Augustine boasts a wide variety of restaurants that specialize in burgers.

Burgers

Savor a bit of the bayou at any of these St. Augustine restaurants that offer Cajun and Creole cuisine.

Cajun/Creole

Enjoy the unique spicy sweet flavors of Caribbean cuisine at one of these restaurants in St. Augustine.

Caribbean

Whether your favorite is latte, espresso, Americano, or iced, you'll find scrumptious coffee or tea at one of these St. Augustine shops.

Coffee / Espresso

Country Food

Find a great selection of Cuban cuisine at one of these St. Augustine restaurants.

Cuban

You'll find a wealth of delicatessens and sandwich/sub shops in St. Augustine.

Deli

Everything from mini-donuts and confectionary cookie dough creations to build-your-own or traditional doughnuts at one of these St. Augustine shops.

Doughnuts

St. Augustine offers a host of fast food restaurants for some quick and easy dining.

Fast Food

From croissants to traditional French country dishes, St. Augustine offers some of the finest French cuisine around.

French

These St. Augustine restaurants offer great German food — everything from sauerkraut and bratwurst to pretzels and kielbasa.

German

A number of St. Augustine restaurants offer gluten-free options on their menus.

Gluten-free

St. Augustine offers some delicious options for traditional Greek food.

Greek

Audience members prior to the Magic Hideaway show, smiling and holding signature cocktails

Happy Hour

Whether your favorite hot dog is Chicago, Cincinnati, or Coney Island style, you'll find something to love at one of these St. Augustine eateries.

Hot Dogs

These St. Augustine shops serve up ice cream, Italian ice, sorbet, gelato, and frozen yogurt. 

Ice Cream

These St. Augustine restaurants serve up delicious Indian food, from curry to tikka to naan and tandoori.  

Indian

Corned beef and cabbage is just one of many Irish specialties offered at these St. Augustine restaurants and pubs.

Irish

Japanese

Latin American

From couscous and pastas to tapas and tabbouleh, delicious Mediterranean food is offered at these St. Augustine restaurants.

Mediterranean

St. Augustine offers a host of eateries that specialize in Mexican food.

Mexican

Pancakes and waffles are served at a variety of restaurants in St. Augustine, as diner staples, Southern specialties, and more.

Pancakes/Waffles

Find your favorite pizza — from New York style to Chicago deep-dished to vegan specialties — at one of these St. Augustine eateries.

Pizza

St. Augustine offers mouth-watering Polish food (like kielbasa, kaput kiszony, and smietana) at a couple of restaurants.

Polish

Heroes, subs, pitas, salads, wraps, gyros and more can be found at any of these St. Augustine restaurants.

Sandwiches

Whether it's collard greens, pork, oxtail, or traditional soul food you're looking for, you'll find it at one of these St. Augustine restaurants.

Soul Food

Delicious soups and salads are available at these St. Augustine restaurants.

Soup & Salad

Serving everything from fried chicken to biscuits and gravy and corn bread to shrimp and grits, these eateries offer all the comfort of classic Southern food.

Southern

These local spots are perfect for your favorite football, soccer, baseball, or basketball games.

Sports Bar

Here's a listing of the St. Augustine restaurants that offer mouth-watering sushi and sashimi.

Sushi

Tapas bars traditionally offer a wide variety of Spanish style foods as appetizers, from seafood to pork and vegetarian dishes.

Tapas

Cuisine from Thailand is usually a mix of sweet and sour flavors, with chicken, pork, seafood, and beef.

Thai

St. Augustine has a number of restaurants that offer vegan meals, and a few that offer a plant-based menu.

Vegan Friendly

These St. Augustine restaurants serve fresh vegetable, vegetarian, and vegan dishes, many of these locally sourced.

Vegetarian

The Reef Restaurant deck view to the Atlantic ocean in the background

Waterfront