Seafood Restaurants

Find seafood restaurants with fresh fish and shellfish!

St. Augustine is a port town and as such we offer fresh, off-the-docks seafood! Our seafood restaurants serve up fresh and delicious entrees every day of the week. From shrimp, to scallops, oysters, fish, and more; the seafood St. Augustine offers is fresh and prepared how you like it. Order blackened, fried, grilled, steamed, baked, and broiled seafood entrees. 

Browse below to find a variety of seafood restaurants including picturesque dining on the water or in historic downtown. Most of the restaurants source fish straight from boats gathering in the Atlantic Ocean and in Florida's freshwater rivers. If you don't have time to hop on a charter yourself, you'll find plenty of tasty dishes for all of you visitors who long for the salt life.

Cap's on the Water

(904) 824-8794
4325 Myrtle Street
Enjoy the sunset over the Matazas River while dining on some delicious Old Florida cuisine at St. Augustine's Cap's on the Water.

Cap's on the Water offers waterfront dining overlooking the Matanzas River with local seafood and Old Florida cuisine in St. Augustine.

Casa Benedetto's

(904) 471-5999
197F Blackford Way
The entrace for the new Casa Benedetto's in St. Augustine.

Formerly in Vilano, this family-run Italian restaurant has moved to a new location off Dixie highway south of St. Augustine.

Casa Maya Mexican Seafood Grille & Tequila Bar

(904) 823-0787
22 Hypolita Street
The Casa Maya is located on Hypolita Street, just a block from the bayfront in historic St. Augustine, Florida.

Casa Maya offers Latin American cuisine in a charming setting in St. Augustine's historic district.

Catch 27

(904) 217-3542
40 Charlotte Street

Fresh, local seafood in the heart of historic downtown St. Augustine.

Cellar 6

(904) 827-9055
6 Aviles Street
The cozy bar inside Cellar 6 on Aviles Street in St. Augustine.

Cellar 6 presnts urban cuisine in an upscale, casual environment.

Centro Restaurant & Piano Bar CLOSED

(904) 891-0318
17 King Street
Centro Piano Bar and Restaurant is located across from the Plaza de la Constitucion in historic St. Augustine.

Centro Restaurant, Piano Bar, and Nightclub has permanently CLOSED.

Collage Restaurant

(904) 829-0055
60 Hypolita Street
Collage Restaurant offers fine international cuisine every night of the week in St. Augustine, FL.

Collage offers fine international cuisine every night of the week.

Conch House Restaurant

(904) 829-8646
57 Comares Avenue

Conch House Restaurant is a St. Augustine staple known for their waterside dining and Caribbean flavors.

Conrad's Steakhouse

(904) 794-9440
4010 US 1 South

This family-owned restaurant south of St. Augustine on U.S. 1 specializes in steak and seafood.

Creekside Dinery

(904) 829-6113
160 Nix Boatyard Road

Taste some Old Florida cooking at this local dinery, with live music, happy hour specials, and quaint outdoor and indoor dining.

Crescent Beach Bar & Grill

(904) 250-0895
6975 A1A South
The exterior of Crescent Beach Bar & Grill in St. Augustine.

Crescent Beach Bar and Gill is a bar for gathering, music, and sports with great food.

Florida Cracker Cafe

(904) 829-0397
81 St. George St.
The Florida Cracker Café is located in the heart of St. Augustine' historic district.

Enjoy Florida-style cuisine at this downtown restaurant, which offers indoor dining as well as a large outdoor patio with shaded seating.

Fresh Market Island

(904) 417-0550
110 A Anastasia Blvd.

Fresh Market Island features fresh foods from Florida and flavors from around the world.

Gourmet Hut

(904) 824-7477
17 Cuna Street

Gourmet Hut offers signature dishes for breakfast and an ever-changing farm to table menu for lunch and dinner.

Green Papaya

(904) 516-8888
841 Ponce de Leon Blvd.

This restaurant offers beautifully presented Thai and sushi dishes.

Grille Room

(904) 940-3200
205 St Johns Golf Drive

Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are served on select days and times at the Grille Room at the St. Johns Golf and Country Club.

Gypsy Cab Company

(904) 824-8244
828 Anastasia Blvd
Gypsy Cab Company in St. Augustine offers a unique, urban style menu!

Gypsy Cab Company features an urban cuisine menu showcasing St. Augustine seasonal variety.

Harry's Seafood Bar & Grille

(904) 824-7765
46 Avenida Menendez
Harry's Seafood Bar and Grille is located on the bayfront, in the heart of downtown St. Augustine.

This New Orleans-style restaurant offers courtyard seating, a lively bar and intimate indoor tables and booths.

Harvest & Reel

(904) 461-9004
300 A1A Beach Blvd
Dinner at Harvest & Reel in the Embassy Suites by Hilton Oceanside Resort on St. Augustine Beach.

Harvest and Reel serves meals made from fresh, local, ingredients — prepared simply.

Hurricane Patty's Bar and Grill

(904) 342-7338
69 Lewis Blvd.

Waterfront dining, live music, a full bar, and great seafood entrees are available at Hurricane Patty's.