13 Florida Foods In St. Augustine

Vacationers looking for authentic Florida food can pull up a chair at St. Augustine's restaurants.

  • Most people say that the best food the world has to offer is in Italy. Oh yeah, pizza and noodles, really impressive. Others favor the French. Mmm, snails—thanks, but no thanks.

    Well, all those people are way wrong! Obviously, the best food ever created in the history of culture is the food we have right here in the great state of Florida.

    The thing about Florida food, though, is that just like American food, very few dishes are really “our own.” Instead, Florida brings together a multitude of cultural influences and cuisines from different regions.

    We have Latin influences, rich seafood delicacies, and Southern comfort food (yeah, that’s right. I said it. Florida is part of the South. Has been since 1845, so deal with it.). With such a long history and so many different cooking cultures contributing to the food industry in St. Augustine, visitors on vacation here can definitely enjoy all the dishes that the state of Florida is famous for.

    Southern Food

    As they say, “in Florida, the further north you go, the further south you get.” What they mean by this is that a lot of Central and North Florida is characterized by Southern culture.

    The areas around St. Augustine were settled by colonial-era English and American pioneers known as Florida Crackers. These crackers were cattlemen who lived and worked in the backcountry. Their culinary tradition included a lot of the dishes the South is known for, including barbeque, shrimp and grits, fried green tomatoes, and more.

    European Food

    The Spanish were the first to land and claim Florida for Europe, and the first Europeans to ring the dinner bell in Florida. The Spanish brought over a lot of awesome dishes that are still popular today, like ceviche, empanadas, arroz con pollo … the list goes on.

    And it wasn’t only Spanish who brought their special foods to Florida -- Minorcan and Greek immigrants also had a huge influence on St. Augustine dishes. Dishes utilizing the local datil pepper-like Minorcan chowder are a staple in town. And yes, even the Italians with their delicious pizza and noodles.

    Floribbean Food

    All the seafood and tropical delicacies that Florida is known for are found easily in St. Augustine. Because St. Augustine, Florida is a seaside town, the fishing industry is the perfect supply point for Caribbean influenced or “Floribbean” dishes. It also means that "Catch of the Day" is a special at most restaurants, and people actually get legitimately excited about oyster season.>

    1. Conch Fritters

    Conchs are a form of sea snail, and conch fritters are when these sea snails are mixed up into a delicious batter, deep-fried, and served as an appetizer at local seafood restaurants. Conch fritters are like the escargot of Florida, except far more appetizing. Conch fritters are a good mix of Southern-influenced cooking and seafood (the Southern influence mainly coming from the fact that they’re deep-fried in a big vat of oil) and dipped in rich, creamy tartar.

    Visitors who want to try conch fritters can order them at The Conch House (of course) located on Anastasia just a bit over the Bridge of Lions.

    Make Your Own

    CONCH FRITTERS

    2 cups self-rising flour
    2 cups conch, tenderized and finely chopped
    1 large onion, diced
    1 green pepper, diced
    2 dashes of tabasco sauce
    2 eggs, slightly beaten
    ¾ cup milk (approximately)
    salt and pepper to taste

    Combine all of the above ingredients with enough milk for the mixture to hold its shape. Form into fritters and deep fry in 350 degrees oil until golden. Drain onto paper towels and serve with a sauce of your choice.

    2. Fresh Catch of the Day

    Being a peninsula surrounded by water on 3 sides in Florida means that “Fresh Catch of the Day” is about as fresh as it gets (well, fresher than if you ordered Fresh Catch of the Day in Oklahoma). This menu topper allows visitors to enjoy the most local of cuisines caught right from the Atlantic Ocean and the Matanzas River.

    Popular fresh catches in St. Augustine, Florida include flounder, snapper, and drum. Another great thing about Fresh Catch of the Day as a Florida food is the fact that it can be served in a variety of ways: grilled, blackened, or fried.

    Visitors can try the fresh catch at many local seafood restaurants, including Catch 27.

    3. Shrimp & Grits

    Florida’s proximity to the Caribbean provides a strong Creole influence on its cooking scene. A popular Southern dish, Shrimp and Grits, comes from this Creole culinary tradition and is a tasty seafood dish served for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The hearty dish combines low-country grits with fresh seafood for a rich Florida taste.

    Visitors to St. Augustine can find Shrimp and Grits at Harry’s Seafood, a Cajun restaurant chain founded in Florida.

    4. Gator Tail

    You can often get a feel for local cuisine by trying some of the local game or ordering a catch of the day; whether it’s from the ocean or a swamp. Yes, gator is an actual dish in some Florida restaurants, and the game is in abundance here with over 1 million alligators in the state! The tail is deep-fried and served as an appetizer or as an entree.

    Wondering what gator tail tastes like? It’s different for everyone, but for me, it’s like a half-chicken, half-fish hybrid, which makes sense if you lean towards the theory that early reptilian dinosaurs were covered in feathers.

    Visitors can dine on this reptilian delicacy at Florida Cracker Café on St. George Street. You can’t miss it because the logo is an alligator saying “Let’s eat my tail!” Ok, he’s only saying “Let’s eat,” but what else can he mean when he’s the one who’s on the menu.

    5. Key Lime Pie

    Key Lime Pie is one nice slice of baked good that has its origins in the Florida keys and is made with key lime juice, egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk, and a pie crust. A real Key Lime pie will be yellow, because even though Key Limes are green, the juice is yellow. Key Lime Pie has a sweet and tart taste to it, and is often topped with whipped cream and garnished with a slice of lime.

    In St. Augustine, Key Lime Pie is a signature dessert at many eateries. Visitors can try this timeless Florida dessert at Raintree Restaurant.

    Make Your Own

    KEY LIME PIE

    6 egg yolks, beaten slightly
    1 can sweetened condensed milk
    7 large Key limes, juiced (1/2 cup)
    1 baked pie shell (9-inch)
    6 egg whites
    12 tablespoons sugar

    Combine egg yolks and condensed milk and mix well. Add lime juice and blend. Turn into pie shell. Bake in moderate oven (350°) until set, about 10 minutes. Meanwhile, beat egg white until stiff. Put on pie by large spoonfuls, spreading to edge of pie shell—place in a hot oven (400°) for 5 minutes. Reduce heat to 300° and bake until meringue is pale honey-colored.

    6. Minorcan Chowder

     

    Minorcans first settled in St. Augustine, Florida back in 1777, and brought with them a rich culinary tradition that is still shared today. Minorcan chowder is a local specialty in St. Augustine, and recipes have been carried down for generations. For an authentic chowder, (made with conch) head to Sunset Grille.

    For more chowder love, visitors can check out The Great Chowder Debate, an annual competition pitting chowder against chowder in a fight to the death.

    Make Your Own

    MINORCAN CLAM CHOWDER

    1 quart of fresh clams
    2 pounds of onions, minced
    2 large cans of tomatoes
    1 datil pepper, minced fine
    1 clove of garlic, minced
    ¼ teaspoon each of thyme, salt, and pepper
    2 lbs. raw potatoes, finely diced

    Brown the minced onions in oil. Add the tomatoes, datil pepper, and garlic. Cook on slow until it is a paste. Meanwhile, boil the finely-diced potatoes until tender, and then add the potatoes with their water to the tomato paste. Add the thyme, salt, pepper. Mince or grind the clams, cover them with water, and cook for 20-minutes. Add the clams and their liquid to the mixture. This will make 3 quarts and can be frozen. — Recipe from "St. Augustine Cookery," published in 1965 by the Flagler Hospital Auxillary.

    7. Barbeque

    Another Florida food that serves the masses of locals and visitors in Florida is barbeque (also known as barbecue, BBQ, or Bar-B-Q). Barbeque styles in America vary from region to region depending on the type of wood available to cook with, the different sauces used to marinate meats, and species of cattle, hog, and other livestock used for meat.

    North Florida is known for founding many popular barbeque chains, including Bono’s BBQ in Jacksonville and Sonny’s BBQ in Gainesville. Each of these purveyors of Florida barbeque have locations in St. Augustine, in the vicinity of the Ponce de Leon region. Also along U.S. 1, locals often grab an order to go from a St. Augustine favorite, Smokin' D's, which has two locations — appropriately named Smokin' D's North and Smokin' D's South. (I'm serious about the to-go part. Neither of the Smokin' D's has inside seating, and the outside seating is rustic.) In the Historic Downtown, try Mojo's Old City BBQ, one outpost of a popular Northeast Florida chain. And finally, those who want to take a drive to the St. Johns River, must try Woodpecker's Backyard Barbeque on Route 13.

    With Florida barbeque, visitors to these restaurants can also get all the Southern fixins: corn fritters, green beans, coleslaw, cornbread, and more.

    8. Oysters

    When oysters come in, it’s everyone’s favorite time to head to the seafood restaurant and slurp down on some shellfish. It’s easy to know if it’s a good month for oysters – if the month has an “r” in it, you’re good! Some eat straight from the shell, others plop it on a Saltine with horseradish and cocktail sauce. There’s no wrong way to eat oyster (unless you’re putting it on top of an ice cream sundae). Visitors who want to try some oysters can order them at Salt Life Food Shack.

    9. Ceviche

    Ceviche is a Latin appetizer and Florida food that showcases the power of the sunshine state’s abundant citrus crops. It was popularized in Florida by Spanish conquistadors and colonizers. The dish has raw fish that is naturally cooked with a magical chemical reaction produced by citric acids in lemons, limes, and oranges. It’s like Florida’s science and space industry meets citrus crops meets seafood, and it’s amazing. Llama Restaurant on Anastasia Island, Casa Maya, and the Colombia Restaurant downtown district are all great options for local ceviche.

    10. Cuban Sandwich (The Cubano)

    Origins of its popularity sprung from Miami and Tampa, but the Cuban Sandwich, also known as the Cubano, has become the unofficial official state sandwich for Florida. The sandwich is made with roasted pork, ham, melted Swiss cheese, mustard, pickles, all pressed inside some warm and toasty Cuban bread. The Cubano is great with potato chips, fries, but let's be honest, they're best with plantain chips.

    The Cuban Sandwich can be ordered at a number of St. Augustine locations, including Taberna del Caballo on St. George Street, and La Herencia Café on Aviles Street.

    11. Fried Green Tomatoes

    Green tomatoes on their own are pretty gross (mostly because I absolutely abhor the taste of tomatoes period, but also because they're not ripe) but FRIED green tomatoes, that’s a different story. Fried green tomatoes are green tomato slices, dipped in batter, fried, and seasoned. From there, they can be dipped in blue cheese, ranch, spicy mayonnaise, or even mustard.

    Visitors who want to try Fried Green Tomatoes can try them as an appetizer, or on a Fried Green Tomato BLT at The Blue Hen.

    12. Empanadas

    A lot of traditional Spanish dishes have worked their way into mainstream American culture. One is the empanada. But the empanadas we’re talking about aren’t your run-of-the-mill fast-food entrée. Visitors looking to try real empanadas can find them at St. Augustine’s Spanish Bakery.

    The dough and filling are made from scratch and the empanadas are hand-rolled. And just like in the old days, they’re thrown into a microwave and cooked to perfection (JK, it’s a real old-fashioned stone oven with actual fiery flames that burn).

    13. Arroz con Pollo

    Arroz con pollo, or Rice with Chicken, is a popular dish in Florida. The dish has Spanish and Puerto Rican roots and is often offered as an entrée at many Florida restaurants. The chicken and rice is sometimes served with red or black beans, and seasoned with peppers.

    The Columbia has an Arroz con Pollo plate available on their Spanish-inspired, Floridian menu.

    Fabulous Florida Drinks That Quench Our Thirst

    In the heat of Florida, staying hydrated is important. No one does drinks better than us.

    • Orange Juice- The orange is Florida’s cash crop, and orange juice is the official drink of Florida.
    • Mimosas - Champagne and orange juice--you’re welcome.
    • Margaritas - It’s always a tough choice whether to have this citrusy drink frozen like a slushy or on the rocks, but both keep plenty of Floridians cool during those warm summer months.
    • Mojitos - The mint makes this drink feel like drinking a breath of fresh air. If you order a mojito at the Columbia, it comes with a stalk of sugar cane in it.
    • Bloody Marys - Southerners in Florida love their spice, and the Bloody Mary usually packs a punch; especially when it’s made with Vodka from the St. Augustine Distillery.
    • Iced Coffee - Hot coffee sounds like a death wish most of the year. Floridians prefer their coffee on the rocks.
    • Sweet Tea - Like the Northerner’s Iced Tea, except better. Because there’s sugar in it.
    • Arnie Palmer - Popularized by the famous golfer who eventually settled here in Florida. Half sweet tea, half lemonade, all citrusy, Southern, and pure Florida.
    • Grapefruit Juice - Indian River not from concentrate to get the purest juice. It’s bitter at first, but it’s an acquired taste and definitely quenches the thirst of Floridians.




  • Comments or Questions?

    happy floribbbeean ddddddaaaay

    key lime pie is what Florida is best known for

    Add new Comment

Article Keywords

Updated: Thursday, July 23, 2020

Alex's picture
Alex Pooler

As Content Editor for VisitStAugustine.com, Alex writes and edits everything from articles to business profiles to events. She likes manatees, orange juice, and getting into a hot car on a scorchingly hot Florida summer day after being in AC for hours.